Our Reporter, Abuja
Manchester United’s troubled 2025-26 season took a devastating turn as they suffered a historic 12-11 penalty shootout loss to League Two side Grimsby Town in the second round of the EFL Cup at Blundell Park. The defeat, following a 2-2 draw in regulation time, marks one of the most humiliating results in the club’s storied history and piles further pressure on manager Ruben Amorim.
Grimsby Town, a fourth-tier outfit with a squad value dwarfed by United’s £750 million roster, stunned the Red Devils with a spirited performance. The Mariners took a commanding 2-0 lead by halftime, capitalizing on United’s defensive frailties. Charles Vernam opened the scoring in the 22nd minute, beating goalkeeper André Onana with a low shot after a pinpoint cross from Darragh Burns. Eight minutes later, Tyrell Warren doubled the lead, pouncing on an Onana error to send the 9,000-capacity crowd into a frenzy.
United fought back late with goals from Bryan Mbeumo (75th minute) and Harry Maguire (89th minute), forcing the match into a penalty shootout. However, the marathon 26-penalty showdown saw Grimsby goalkeeper Christy Pym emerge as the hero, saving Matheus Cunha’s spot-kick and scoring his own, before Mbeumo’s second attempt struck the crossbar, sealing Grimsby’s historic victory. Jubilant home fans stormed the pitch, chanting “Premier League, you’re having a laugh” as United’s players trudged off in disgrace.
“It’s an unbelievable feeling, one that will live on forever,” said Vernam, a Grimsby native, to Sky Sports. Manager David Artell credited his team’s fearless approach, noting, “The gaffer told us all the pressure was on them, and we played like it.”
For Manchester United, the loss adds to an already dismal start to the season. Winless in their first three matches, including a 15th-place finish in the Premier League last season, the Red Devils are grappling with a crisis of confidence. Amorim, whose 3-4-3 system has failed to click, faced criticism for his tactics and body language, with reports noting he remained in the dugout during the shootout, appearing defeated.
“We were completely lost,” Amorim admitted post-match, acknowledging the team’s lackluster performance.
Social media erupted with memes targeting Amorim’s tactics board, and fans voiced their frustration.
“This is worse than MK Dons in 2014,” one supporter posted on Reddit, referencing another infamous United cup exit. Grimsby’s squad, valued at just £3 million compared to United’s Bruno Fernandes’ £19.5 million annual wage alone, exposed the gulf in mentality despite the financial disparity.
This defeat marks United’s first-ever EFL Cup loss to a fourth-tier side, joining a list of historic upsets against lower-division teams like York City (1995) and Southend (2006). With Amorim’s job security now in question, the club faces a daunting task to regroup ahead of their next Premier League fixture. For Grimsby, the night will be etched in folklore as they advance to the third round, dreaming of more giant-killing exploits.
As the dust settles on Blundell Park, one thing is clear: Manchester United’s woes show no signs of abating, while Grimsby Town’s heroics will be celebrated for generations.
